Guys with Dicks became a proper four-piece group on A ROOMFUL OF SEXINESS, only for things to shift again when Andrew moved to another city at the end of the school year. We were whittled back down to a three-piece.
I thought that might be the end of us. Instead, something clicked in a way it never had before, and we became a whole new band.
It didn’t hurt that I was in the middle of a tumultuous long-distance “relationship”, which looked like it was just ending after threatening to turn into something tangible, and working as a telemarketer — at the same time. I’d only been doing the job for a few weeks, and it was my first paying gig out of high school, so it was still sort of exciting in a weird way. Brain rot hadn’t set in yet. It was a little like entering a bizarro universe for eight hours every day.
Those two things (the dead relationship and the new job) informed the lyrics I was improvising to such an extent that my working title for this album was Sex and Telemarketing. I’m happy to say good taste prevailed when it was time to replace that working title with something permanent, and I thought of something a little more interesting.
The actual album title is a response to — and an acknowledgement of — some things Tyson said. We were having a lot of long conversations at the time. It was a sort of getting-to-know-each-other-more-intimately process of philosophizing and throwing ideas around as we were becoming closer friends and more of a real band. A lot of these conversations took place on my side porch while Tyson was smoking a cigarette.
When I told him this was some of the most intense music I’d ever made, he thought that was a little funny. For him our songs were relaxing. I guess next to the brutal sonic assault of the music he was making with Fetal Pulp and ADHD, it would be. But for me, there wasn’t anything relaxing about it.
I explained that it was emotional intensity I was talking about — what I was singing about and where it was coming from. This was the most desperate, most honest music I’d ever made up to this point. I’d never allowed myself to be this unguarded before.
So the album title gave a nod to the idea that while what was feeding the songs might have been unpleasant and autobiographical for me, it didn’t mean everyone else was going to pick up on it.
I wasn’t in a great place at the time. I decided to stop role-playing and start singing about what I was really feeling and thinking — not something I was doing much of in the music I’d been making over the past few years. Instead of trying on different characters and voices I was singing as myself for the first time in a long time, and doing it in a way I never had before.
I started using the guitar and the voice as cathartic tools instead of trying to make pleasing or interesting sounds. I wanted to make the music feel my pain. At the end of Voyeur, I took out all of my anger on the guitar without any thought given to what I was playing. It was a little like I was possessed. It felt unnerving, exciting, necessary.
While I was working out the anger and bitterness, a whole lot of sexual lyrics came falling out. What was little more than silliness on A ROOMFUL OF SEXINESS, where I was trying on the clothes just to see how they fit, now had more of an edge to it. Some of it doesn’t sound far off from misogyny, though I’ve never waded into that stupid river even in my angriest moments.
This was just how my frustration found expression. I was pretty sure I would never get to experience any kind of intimacy with anyone. I figured if I couldn’t have what all the other guys I knew seemed to be getting even when some of them were pretty shitty people, at least I could sing about it. As a sexually frustrated teenager in a group of slightly less sexually frustrated teenagers, I didn’t see the point in censoring myself. There were some darker, somewhat suicidal thoughts at play as well (made most explicit in Dance on My Brain), but it would take a few more albums before they really came to a boil.
A few of these songs were meant for a projected solo album, even if they were little more than sketches (Voyeur and Nicotine and Beer only had about a verse apiece). I would have recorded them on my own at some point, I’m sure, but when it became clear how well we were playing off of one another I stopped thinking about recording anything by myself and just hit the record button and improvised those songs into a state of completion with Gord and Tyson.
The three of us only played together once in the five months before we started working on this album. There was one very casual jam session in the summer when we tried messing around as a trio for the first time in a long while, and that was it. But it didn’t feel like it. It felt like we’d somehow been woodshedding the whole time.
We were never anywhere near this tight before. Maybe breaking things down to the bare bones forced us to realize our true potential as a band. It felt like we were somehow stronger now that we were less than we’d been before. There was more space for each of us to work with, and out of that space came clear roles for everyone for the first time.
Tyson’s drumming became a lot more creative and unpredictable, full of dynamic shifts and unexpected fills. Gord’s bass-playing was all over the place, at once filling in the low end and throwing in melodic jabs. For my part, I played guitar better than I ever had in my life, and the singing was some of my most committed vocal work in a long time, wiping the floor with my inconsistent work in front of the microphone on A ROOMFUL OF SEXINESS.
None of us could believe this stuff was coming out of us. After we finished recording Dance on My Brain at the end of the album’s first recording session, Tyson had a look on his face like he’d just emerged from a near-death experience.
“I think we just became better musicians while we were playing that,” he said, mesmerized.
The morning after that first session, I ran into Tyson at the bus stop on my way to work and his way to school. We agreed the night before had produced some of the best music either one of us had ever been a part of. A quiet moment passed between us and we both acknowledged we were a little in awe of what was happening. We didn’t know we could be this good together, and we didn’t even put in any rehearsal time to make it happen or sit down and try to write the songs. It came out of nowhere.
What followed was one of the great musical adventures of my life, and some much-needed therapy. I managed to get properly stoned on pot for the first time in the middle of it all. Tyson filmed me doing a giddy dance in the middle of the street after dark, celebrating my first high.
I threw out the “no overdubs” credo I’d been maintaining through all the GWD CDs for just about the first time when I overdubbed vocal harmonies for the “chorus” of Voyeur. I wasn’t planning on keeping them, but once Tyson heard what I did he was adamant that the harmonies stay. He said they reminded him of Steely Dan, which always mystified me a little.
He talked me into adding harmonies to a few more songs. I wasn’t sure they were a good idea at the end of Ring Around Me, thinking they might take away from the nastiness of what I was saying (now I think they make for a nice little unexpected touch). On Charlatan Shuffle I really wasn’t feeling it at all, so I gave the microphone to Tyson and he overdubbed some great falsetto wailing of his own.
So vocal overdubs were allowed now. That was about it. The music would otherwise remain a live, unfiltered representation of exactly what we sounded like while playing together in the little music room that called itself a studio. There would be no instrumental parts added after the fact (the one exception was a brief drum overdub Tyson asked to graft onto the beginning of Nicotine and Beer to punch it up a little). All the lead vocals would be live with no punch-ins, and guitar solos would be limited to what I improvised in the moment, mistakes and all.
Gord told me Redound changed the way he played bass. It might have changed the way I played electric guitar, too. It was easily the best guitar-playing I’d managed up to that point. I’m not sure where it came from. We were all just improvising as usual, and I wasn’t working from any preconceived melodic ideas.
I never expected to become the only guitarist in a band with anyone. Having to fill in all that space with only a rhythm section to fall back on was a brand new thing for me. It forced me to become a better guitarist pretty much overnight. For some reason, I never found it awkward to have to carry lead and rhythm duties with no guitar overdubs to help me out. I kind of got off on the challenge, even if I fell flat on my face every once in a while.
Dance on My Brain and Vicodin are the album’s epic centerpieces. It’s always felt to me like everything pivots around those two tracks, adding up to more than half an hour of music just between the two of them.
Dance on My Brain got off to a slow start, and I didn’t think it would amount to much. Then I started talking about my new job, and talking about the girl my head was messed up about — just working out some thoughts instead of attempting to sing a song. As I dug deeper, the whole thing kept growing in intensity until I was snarling into the microphone in a more nakedly angry voice than anything I’d ever dared to do on record before. Gord and Tyson were with me every step of the way, shifting from one end of the dynamic spectrum to the other, and when it was over after almost twenty minutes and I was muttering, “That was fucked up,” Tyson had an awed look in his eyes that spoke for all of us. In the space of that one song we more or less discovered a whole new musical language for ourselves without meaning to.
All these years later, Vicodin is still one of my favourite things we ever did as a band. Everything comes full circle and all of the album’s themes meet head-on for one last psychotic hurrah. I somehow manage to work my entire telemarketing spiel into the song (in somewhat mutilated form), along with a pretty cruel dissection of an email and a lot of other twisted shit. The sex talk is there, but it’s bent in a much stranger direction. There’s even a Carpenters reference, of all things.
What’s funny is Tyson wanted to record a ballad to end the album, to mix things up. I wanted to explore this evil, semi-dissonant arpeggio I had on the guitar instead. I can’t imagine what would have happened if I yielded and tried to come up with something gentler (actually, I can — it became the opening track of the very next album). All I know is, I’m glad we got this instead of a ballad.
I love the screams and random noises Gord and Tyson contribute throughout the song, and there are some uncanny moments of rhythm section telepathy between the two of them. One of my favourite bits is the “argument” between me and Gord, with him screaming into a kazoo while I act out the part of a typical womanizing douchebag. It’s music as performance art, sort of, and at the same time it’s just one small part of the insanity going on around it.
Nicotine and Beer was one song I wasn’t so sure about. I wanted to keep it for the soon-to-be abandoned solo CD. It seemed too upbeat to fit in with the rest of the songs here. But once I played part of it for Gord and Tyson they wouldn’t let it back in the bag. It’s probably the closest thing to a radio-friendly song on the album, references to sex and vomiting notwithstanding.
The sound on this album, and the GWD albums that followed, is a pretty serious shift from anything I’d done before. On most of the songs I slathered my voice in slapback echo and left myself somewhat buried in the mix, treating the voice like it was just another instrument, no more or less important than anything else. Some of the inspiration for that came from John Lennon’s Plastic Ono Band — still one of my favourite albums ever made by anyone. I loved that vocal sound, and the sound of the album in general, so raw and stripped-down, but massive and powerful in its nakedness. It was probably the least Spector-esque thing Phil Spector ever produced (accounts vary; some say he never showed up to produce at all), but I can’t imagine it sounding any other way.
I wasn’t much of a producer at the time, though. So instead of spending a lot of time trying to get a specific drum sound, or a specific anything-sound, I set things up in a way that seemed to make sense with the equipment I had, and off we went. To be honest, the main reason I mixed my voice so low was because half the time I didn’t really like my voice that much.
The drum sound was a definite improvement over A ROOMFUL OF SEXINESS, with two mics on the kit this time instead of one. The kick drum mic was positioned in such a way that it picked up some of the snap from the snare, and the lone overhead mic was aimed at Tyson’s lap. That seemed to be the sweet spot. Those two SM57s were all I would use to record drums for the next eight or so albums I made. In hindsight I wish I had the good sense to use a real guitar amp for all of this stuff instead of a POD. But it made the recording process easier, and it did the job well enough.
I have a lot of memories and stories from the band days. It’s one of those things where I could write a book no one would ever want to read. One of the most vivid memories comes from this album. We were in the middle of recording Charlatan Shuffle — the one thing here that’s always felt a little like filler to me — and it got to the part where the groove gets really deep and I’m singing, “Shake it loose,” and kind of scatting.
I looked up at Tyson. We made eye contact. He had this huge smile on his face. I looked over at Gord. He was smiling too. So was I.
I had one of those “wow” moments. It hit me that here I was in a little room between the kitchen and the living room of my house, with two of my best friends, each of us just a few feet away from one another, and we were improvising this music out of nothing and having the time of our lives doing it. We were all thinking and feeling the same thing. I could see it in their eyes. It transcended the bitterness I was pouring into the song. I felt a strong connection, a feeling of being a part of something much larger than myself, and it was powerful. Almost spiritual, in a way.
This strange three-way musical bond we’d built wouldn’t last long. But it was exciting while it did.
Ring Around Me
Until You Lose
Dance on My Brain
Nicotine and Beer